This puzzle starts with a broken four: four stones inside five consecutive points, with one gap, so that filling the gap makes five. The glossary defines it, and it threatens a win as surely as a solid four. Here the broken four opens a forced sequence that ends in a double four on a diagonal. The rules are the site's own: a 15 by 15 board, exactly five in a row wins, six or more does not, and no move is forbidden for either colour.
The position
- Black (6 stones): E11, F9, G8, G11, I11, J8
- White (6 stones): E5, E8, F6, G9, H5, I9
Columns run A to O from left to right and rows 1 to 15 from top to bottom. Black is to move and wins. Black has no five this turn and no four on the board, so every move of the win has to be a four.
Load this position against the computer, and set the level to Hard first. On Easy the computer may leave a four unblocked, and then the line tells you nothing.
Hint: row 11 already holds three of your stones, with two empty points between them. Which of those two points should you play, and what does the forced reply take away from you?
Show the solution
- F11. Row 11 now holds E11, F11 and G11, then an empty H11, then I11. Filling H11 would make exactly five, E11 to I11, with D11 and J11 empty. White has no five of its own, so H11 is forced.
- D11. Row 11 now runs from D11 to G11, four stones, and H11 is White. Only C11 completes five, so White must take C11. D11 also starts a diagonal that runs up and to the right through E10, F9 and G8.
- E10. The diagonal now holds D11, E10, F9 and G8. C12 and H7 each complete exactly five, because B13 and I6 are empty. White can block only one of them, and Black plays the other.
Why H11 is not the answer. It also makes a broken four, with F11 as the gap. But White's forced reply on F11 cuts row 11 in two, and the diagonal sequence never gets started. A script that checks every line of fours to three Black moves, using the win rule from this site's game code, found F11 as the only first move that wins.
What to take from it
- A broken four is a real threat, and the square your opponent must take is its gap. Before you play one, check which of your own stones that forced reply would touch.
- The stones a sequence of fours leaves behind matter as much as the fours. D11 was played only to force C11, yet it is the stone that lets E10 make two fours at once.
- Before you call a chain of fours a win, trace both ends of each line it creates. Here C12 and H7 both had to be empty for the double four to count.
After you solve it, press Undo and play H11 against the computer to see the forced reply on F11. The exactly-five article explains why the end points of a line matter, and the game is there to try the sequence yourself.
Sources
- Gomoku Glossary (broken four, double four, VCF) - Gomoku Live
- Exactly Five versus Renju - Gomoku Live
Play Gomoku at gomokulive.win.
Sources
- Gomoku Glossary — Gomoku Live, 20 October 2026
- Exactly Five versus Renju — Gomoku Live, 2 October 2026
Written by TG, the operator of this site, from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email [email protected] and it will be corrected.