GOMOKU / SITE INFORMATION

Where to Block an Open Three

By Gomoku Live · Published · Updated

When your opponent makes an open three, you usually have to block it. The question this article answers is the next one: where? An open three has two ends, a split three has a gap, and the blocking stone you choose decides what your opponent can still do and what you can build. Every claim about the diagrams was checked by a script using this site’s exact-five rule.

Why an open three must be answered

An open three is three stones in a line with room to become an open four, a four with both ends empty. If you leave it alone, your opponent extends it to an open four, and an open four has two winning squares. You can block only one of them per move, so the game is over. The only exception is when you can answer with a four of your own, which forces your opponent to block and gains you a tempo. Without that, block.

6789101112EFGHIJKLM
Black’s H8, I8 and J8 are an open three. If White ignores it, Black plays G8 or K8 and has an open four.

In the diagram, Black has H8, I8 and J8. The script confirms that only two points turn this into an open four: G8 and K8. Those are the two natural blocks, and either of them is enough to stop the open four. After either block, Black can still make a closed four on the row, but a closed four has only one winning square and can be answered.

Choosing between the two ends

When both ends stop the threat, pick the one that does more for you. Three things to weigh:

  • Your own stones. A block that sits next to your existing stones builds a line of your own while it defends. In the diagram White already has G9 and F10, and G8 is next to G9 and close to F10, while K8 touches no white stone.
  • Your opponent’s other lines. Look along the other three directions through each end point. If one end also lies on a second black line, blocking there spoils two lines at once.
  • The edge of the board. If one end is near the edge, the three is already partly limited on that side. Blocking the other end, the side with more space, often leaves it with no future at all.

The script counts, after each block, the points where one more white stone would give White an open three of its own, a shape that threatens an open four: 7 after G8 and 3 after K8. The difference is the value of blocking next to your own stones. A block is a stone like any other, and it should work for its owner.

Blocking far away does not work

A common beginner error is to block a square or two beyond the end, for example on L8 in the first diagram. That stone does nothing to the open three. The script confirms that Black can still make an open four after it. A block must touch the three’s line at one of the points that would create the open four.

Practise blocking this three

Split threes: block the gap

A split three has the same strength as an open three but a different shape: two stones, a gap, and one more stone, with both outer ends open. In the next diagram Black has G8, H8 and J8, with the gap at I8.

6789101112DEFGHIJKLM
Black’s G8, H8 and J8 form a split three. Filling I8 would give Black an open four.

Here there is only one point that makes an open four, the gap I8, and the script confirms it. Blocking at either outer end, F8 or K8, also prevents the open four. But the three blocks are not equal. After a block in the gap, Black has no points left on the board that make any four at all. After a block on F8 it has 2, and after K8 it has 2. Blocking the gap splits the shape into two short pieces that cannot rejoin, while blocking an end leaves a broken shape that can still become a closed four and be used later as a forcing move.

6789101112DEFGHIJKLM
White fills the gap at I8. The two black pieces of row 8 can no longer join into a four.

That is why the usual advice for split threes is to block in the middle. Leftover closed fours are exactly the raw material your opponent needs for a chain of forcing moves, as the article on continuous fours shows.

A short checklist

  1. Do I have a four I can make first? If so, consider that before blocking.
  2. Which points stop the open four? For an open three, usually the two ends; for a split three, the gap and the two ends.
  3. Of those, which one sits next to my stones or on another of my opponent’s lines?
  4. After my block, how many fours can my opponent still make? Fewer is better.

Defending well is not passive. A player who blocks on the right point keeps the opponent’s attack small and slowly builds a position of their own. For the wider question of whether to defend or counterattack, read attack or defend first.