GOMOKU / SITE INFORMATION

The Double Three

By Gomoku Live · Published · Updated

A double three is a single stone that makes two open threes at the same time. Each three alone could be blocked with one stone. Together they cannot, and the player who makes a double three without being interrupted usually wins. This article shows how it works, why Renju forbids it for Black, and how to stop it before it happens. The diagram claims were checked by a script that applies this site’s exact-five rule and, for the key position, tries every possible White reply.

One stone, two threes

An open three is a threat that has to be answered: if it is ignored, it becomes an open four, which has two winning squares. A double three creates two such threats with one move. The defender blocks one, the attacker extends the other into an open four, and the game ends two moves later. It works for the same reason a fork works in chess: one defending stone cannot do two jobs.

The position before

5678910111213EFGHIJKLM
Black to move. Row 8 has H8 and I8; column J has J9 and J10. Both pairs point at J8.

Black has two pairs: H8 and I8 on row 8, and J9 and J10 in column J. White has four stones nearby, none of them lined up. The script confirms that neither side can make a four in one move, so nothing looks urgent. But both black pairs extend to the same empty point, J8. Row 8 would become H8, I8, J8. Column J would become J8, J9, J10.

Try this position

The double three

Black plays J8.

5678910111213EFGHIJKLM
After J8, Black has an open three on row 8 and another in column J. G8, K8, J7 and J11 would each make an open four.

There are now four points where a black stone would make an open four: G8 and K8 on the row, J7 and J11 in the column. White can occupy only one of them. The script tried every empty point on the board as White’s reply, and in every case Black still had a move making two winning squares, while White never had a four of its own to interrupt with. For example, if White blocks the row with K8, Black plays J11, and column J from J8 to J11 is open at both J7 and J12.

5678910111213EFGHIJKLM
White blocked K8, so Black played J11. The column is an open four: J7 and J12 both win.

Why Renju forbids it for Black

The double three is so strong that the Renju rules forbid it for the first player. In Renju, Black may not make a three-three, a four-four, or an overline of six or more; White may. These restrictions exist to reduce Black’s first-move advantage, which is large in freestyle play. Black can still win with a four-three, a four and a three made at the same time, which is why Renju players study four-threes so carefully.

Gomoku Live uses exact-five rules with no forbidden moves, so a double three is legal for both colours here. The exact-five versus Renju article covers the rule differences in more detail.

How to stop it before it happens

Once the double three is on the board, it is usually too late, unless you have a four of your own. The defence has to come one move earlier. Three habits help:

  • Watch where pairs meet. Two separate twos are harmless alone. When they point at the same empty point, that point is a double-three threat. In the first diagram, a white stone on J8 would have spoiled both pairs at once.
  • Count the threats, not the stones. A position with four black stones can be more dangerous than one with six, if the four are arranged around a shared point.
  • Keep a four in reserve. If you have a closed three that you can turn into a four, you can sometimes answer a double three with that four and then block. A four forces a reply, so it buys exactly one tempo.

Making your own

To set up a double three, build twos in different directions around a common point, ideally while your opponent is busy blocking something else. Diagonals are especially useful, because players tend to scan rows and columns first. When the shared point is still empty and your opponent has no four available, play it. If the shared point also extends a third line, even better: you may get a four-three, which is stronger still because one of the threats is a four. The open shapes page explains the four-three in detail.

One warning about timing. A double three only wins if your opponent has no four to interrupt with. Before playing the shared point, run through your opponent’s lines and check that none of them can become a four in one move. If one can, your opponent will make that four, you must block it, and the extra stone may land exactly on one of your threes. Many promising double threes in casual games are lost this way.

A good exercise is to replay your recent games and mark every point where two of your lines met. Count how many of those points you actually played, and how many your opponent took first.