Most gomoku games between experienced players are not won by one clever stone. They are won by a sequence of threats that leaves the opponent no free move from start to finish. The purest form of that is a VCF, short for victory by continuous fours. This article explains what it is, walks through one example built for this page, and shows how to look for one in your own games. Every claim about the diagrams below, which squares win and which replies are forced, was checked by a script that applies this site’s exact-five rule.
Why a four is the strongest threat
A four is a line of four stones of one colour that can become five with one more stone. If it is closed at one end, there is exactly one winning square. The opponent has no choice: unless they can make five themselves on the spot, they must put a stone on that square, because otherwise you complete the five next turn. A four therefore takes away your opponent’s freedom for one move.
An open three is also a threat, but a weaker one. The defender can block either end, and sometimes a nearby square works too. More importantly, the defender may answer an open three with a four of their own, which gains time. Against a four there is no such escape. That is why a chain made only of fours is the most reliable way to win: from the first four to the last, the opponent never gets to choose.
The idea of continuous fours
A VCF is a sequence in which every move you make is a four, every reply is the forced block, and the last move makes two fours at once, or a four that is open at both ends. Each four does two jobs. It forces the reply, and it also adds a stone that will help a later line. The final position has two winning squares, and one defending stone cannot cover both.
Renju players and gomoku programs search for VCF lines systematically, because when one exists the game is decided. For a human, the practical skill is noticing the raw material: closed threes and broken shapes that can each be turned into a four, and that share stones or meet at useful points.
The starting position
At first sight Black has nothing urgent. The three on row 8, from F8 to H8, is closed by White on E8. Column I has only I9 and I10, with White sitting on I12. Row 11 has F11 and G11. A defender scanning for open threes would find none. And yet Black has a forced win, because these three weak lines connect through two points, I8 and I11.
Try this positionFour number one
Black plays I8. Row 8 becomes F8 to I8, four stones. E8 is White’s, so the only winning square is J8, and White must take it. Notice that I8 also lengthens column I: it now reads I8, I9, I10.
Four number two
Black plays I11. Column I is now I8 to I11. The top end, I12, is White’s, so again there is one winning square, I7, and White must block there. But I11 has also joined row 11: F11, G11 and I11, with a single gap at H11.
The finishing move
Black fills the gap with H11. Row 11 is now F11, G11, H11 and I11, and both ends, E11 and J11, are empty. That is an open four: two winning squares. White can block one; Black plays the other and makes exactly five.
Compare what happens if Black plays H11 straight away, without the first two fours. Row 11 then holds only F11, G11 and H11, an open three, not a four. White has a free move, and Black has given away the surprise. The two forcing moves were needed to put a stone on I11 without letting White react.
How to look for a VCF
- List your fours. Find every empty point where one of your stones would make a four. Closed threes and broken threes are the usual source.
- Look at the new stone, not only the four. After each four, check which other lines the new stone joins. A four that also builds a second line is the one that keeps the chain going.
- Check the forced reply. The defender’s blocking stone can itself block another of your lines, or start a white line. Place it in your head before going on.
- Make sure the opponent cannot make five. If your opponent already has a four, you must block it first. A VCF only works when the opponent has no immediate win.
As a defender, the lesson is the reverse. Closed shapes matter too. When several of your opponent’s closed lines point at the same few empty points, put a stone on one of those points while you still have a free move. The shapes that lose games are often not the open threes everyone watches, but the quiet lines that join up. For the shapes themselves, see open three, open four and broken four; for the general question of when to attack, see attack or defend first.