This puzzle is about the split three: three stones on one line with a single empty point inside them, such as G8 and H8 with J8 added and I8 left empty. Many players read it as a weaker shape than a solid three. On this site it is just as dangerous, because filling the gap can produce an open four. The rules here are the site's own: a 15 by 15 board, exactly five in a row wins, six or more does not, and no move is forbidden for either colour.
The position
- Black (4 stones): G8, H8, J9, J10
- White (4 stones): E4, M12, C13, O5
Columns run A to O from left to right and rows 1 to 15 from top to bottom, as on the board. Black is to move. No single Black move makes a four, because no line holds more than two Black stones yet, so the win has to come from a double threat of threes.
Load this position against the computer. Set the level to Hard first, so the computer defends properly.
Hint: look for one empty square that lies on two lines at once. Ask what each line looks like after that stone, and which squares White must take to stop it.
Show the solution
- J8. This stone does two jobs. On row 8 it makes G8, H8, an empty I8, and J8: a split three with F8 and K8 both empty. On column J it makes J8, J9 and J10: an open three with J7 and J11 both empty. White has one move, so it must choose which three to stop.
- If White takes the gap, I8, Black plays J11. Column J now holds J8 to J11, and both J7 and J12 would complete exactly five. White can block only one of them, and Black plays the other.
- If White blocks column J at J7 or J11, Black plays I8. Row 8 now holds G8 to J8 with F8 and K8 empty: an open four, and either end wins.
- If White blocks one end of row 8, F8 or K8, Black plays I8 anyway. That makes a four with only one completing square, so White must take the other end. Black then plays J11, and column J is an open four that White cannot stop.
The solution is the only winning first move. I checked every Black move against every White reply on the full board with a small program written to the site's rules, and only J8 survives. The solid three at I8 is not a winning first move.
On this site the same idea can be practised. Press Undo after loading the position to take back a move; Undo works in computer games, though not in ranked online matches. Then play I8 instead of J8 and see how the computer answers. The open shapes page shows the split three and the broken four on a live board, and the glossary defines the other words used here.
Sources
- Open Three, Open Four, and Broken Four — Gomoku Live
- Gomoku Questions & Answers (Undo, computer levels) — Gomoku Live
- International Rules of Gomoku (Article 4.1 and 4.3, exactly five) — Renju International Federation
Written by TG, the operator of this site, from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email [email protected] and it will be corrected.