GOMOKU / SITE INFORMATION

Puzzle: a four that makes an open three, and the block that spoils the other

By Gomoku Live · Published · Updated

This puzzle is about the four-three: one stone that makes a four and an open three at the same time. It is one of the most common ways to win in gomoku, and it works here under the site's own rules: a 15 by 15 board, exactly five in a row wins, six or more does not, and nothing is forbidden for either colour.

The position

  • Black (5 stones): I12, J12, K9, K10, K11
  • White (5 stones): E3, G12, K7, K13, O1

Columns run A to O from left to right and rows 1 to 15 from top to bottom, as on the board. Black is to move and wins.

Black's three in column K is closed at both ends by White, K7 and K13, so it can only become a four in two ways: K8, which leaves K12 as the one square that completes five, or K12, which leaves K8. Row 12 already holds I12 and J12. Only one of the two fours also builds a second threat.

Load this position against the computer, with the level set to Hard. Play Black's first move, then watch what the computer does.

Hint: two moves make a four. Ask which of them also makes an open three, and which square White is forced to take.

Show the solution
  1. K12. Column K now runs K9 to K12. It is a four, and the only square that completes five is K8, because K7 and K13 are White. White must play K8. At the same moment row 12 holds I12, J12 and K12, an open three: H12 and L12 are empty, and so are the squares beyond them.
  2. L12. Row 12 now holds I12 to L12, four stones with both ends open. H12 would complete H12 to L12, and M12 would complete I12 to M12. H12 gives exactly five, because G12 is White, so it does not make six. White can block only one of the two squares.
  3. White blocks one end, and Black plays the other for five.

Why K8 fails. It is also a four, and it looks the same from a distance. But White's forced reply is K12, the one square Black needed on row 12. After that the three in row 12 is dead, and the four in column K has nothing behind it. The same stones are on the board; only the forced block decides the game.

Why H12 and L12 fail as first moves. Neither is a four, so White gets a free move. The search found no forced win after either of them.

What to take from it

  • A four and an open three in one move wins only if the square the defender must take is not on the three. Before you play, look at the forced reply and check whether it touches your second line.
  • An open three needs room on both sides. Here I12, J12 and K12 have H12 and L12 empty, and the squares beyond them, G12 and M12, decide whether the next move is an open four or only a closed one.

To see the difference, press Undo after loading the position and play K8 against the computer. Watch it answer on K12, then try K12 and see the open four appear. The glossary defines four-three and the other shapes used here.

Sources

Written by TG, the operator of this site, from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email [email protected] and it will be corrected.

All Gomoku news · Play Gomoku now