GOMOKU / SITE INFORMATION

Puzzle: two double threes, and only one survives the counter-four

By Gomoku Live · Published · Updated

This puzzle is about the double three: one stone that makes two open threes at once. Renju forbids it for Black. On this site it is legal for both colours, so it is a real weapon here.

The position

  • Black (9 stones): H6, H7, F8, G8, I12, L11, L12, J13, K13
  • White (9 stones): G6, J7, F9, I9, I10, I11, M10, K11, H12

Columns run A to O from left to right and rows 1 to 15 from top to bottom, as on the board. The rules are the site's own: 15 by 15, exactly five in a row wins, six or more does not, and nothing is forbidden.

Black to move and win. Black has no four to play, and no chain of fours wins either, so the attack has to start with threes. There are two squares where one stone makes two open threes: H8 in the centre, and L13 lower right. Only one of them wins.

Load this position against the computer, with the level set to Hard.

Hint: before you play a double three, look for a four your opponent can make, and ask which square it lands on.

Show the solution
  1. L13. Row 13 now holds J13, K13 and L13, with I13 and M13 empty and room beyond them. Column L holds L11, L12 and L13, with L10 and L14 empty. Both are open threes.
  2. White can stop only one. If White takes L10 or L14, Black plays I13 or M13 and has an open four on row 13. If White blocks row 13, Black plays L10 or L14 for an open four in column L. Either way Black makes exactly five on the next move.
  3. White can first make a four on column I, at I8 or I7, since I12 is already Black. Black fills the one remaining square. That move costs White its turn too, and both threes are still standing.

Why H8 fails. It makes F8, G8, H8 and H6, H7, H8, two open threes as well. But White answers on I8, which closes row 8 at the I end and makes the four I8 to I11 at the same time. Black must spend the next move on I7, and White then blocks column H. Black is left with nothing forcing. The site's computer on Hard finds I8 too.

A script built on the win check from this site's game code tried every first move near the stones. L13 was the only one that forces a win within four Black moves, with White allowed to answer on any of the 206 empty intersections each time. After H8, White's I8 leaves Black with no forced win in that range, and Black has no win by fours alone in this position.

What to take from it

  • A double three is only as good as the defender's fours. If the opponent can make a four whose stone also blocks one of your threes, they win back the tempo.
  • Check this before you play, not after: look for any three or broken three of theirs that runs through an end square of one of your threes.
  • In renju, the International Rules make a black double three like either of these a losing move. Under exact-five rules there is no such restriction, which is one reason gomoku games here can turn so quickly.

After you solve it, press Undo and play H8 instead to watch the counter-four happen. The open shapes article covers threes and fours, and the glossary defines the double three and four-three.

Sources

Written by TG, the operator of this site, from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email [email protected] and it will be corrected.

All Gomoku news · Play Gomoku now